Comparing the Best Paint Brands: Behr, Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, Valspar, and McCormick

Choosing the right paint can be overwhelming with so many options available. Behr, Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, Valspar, and McCormick each bring unique strengths to the table, whether you’re seeking durability, affordability, or a specific aesthetic.

At Todd A. Hess Painting Co., we understand how vital it is to match the right paint to your specific needs. With years of experience and a focus on quality, we aim to demystify the process and guide you toward the best choice for your project.

1. Behr

Best For: Homeowners looking for affordable, accessible paint with great coverage.
Price Range: $$

Behr is a favorite among DIY homeowners due to its availability at Home Depot and its reliable performance. Behr’s Premium Plus and Marquee lines are praised for their strong coverage and reasonable price point. However, for high-traffic areas or projects requiring a high-end finish, other brands may outperform.

Pros: Affordable, great coverage, easy to find.
Cons: Durability and finish may not match premium brands.

2. Sherwin-Williams

Best For: Professional-grade projects requiring durability and exceptional results.
Price Range: $$$

Sherwin-Williams is a trusted choice for contractors and discerning homeowners alike. Known for lines like Emerald and Duration, this brand delivers durability, fade resistance, and smooth application. It’s ideal for both interior and exterior projects that demand longevity and high traffic resistance.

Pros: Superior durability, professional-grade finish, vast color selection.
Cons: Higher price point compared to other brands.

3. Benjamin Moore

Best For: Homeowners and designers seeking premium paint with unmatched color accuracy.
Price Range: $$$$

Benjamin Moore is synonymous with luxury and quality. Its Aura and Regal Select lines offer unparalleled coverage, rich colors, and a stunning finish. While it comes at a higher price point, the investment pays off for interior projects where aesthetics are paramount.

Pros: Exceptional color accuracy, premium finish, long-lasting durability.
Cons: Premium pricing; less accessible in big-box stores.

4. Valspar

Best For: Budget-conscious homeowners seeking solid performance.
Price Range: $$

Valspar, found at Lowe’s, offers dependable paint at a more affordable price. With decent coverage and durability, it’s a good option for interior projects in lower-traffic areas. However, it doesn’t deliver the same level of results as more premium brands.

Pros: Budget-friendly, decent performance, widely available.
Cons: Limited durability and fade resistance compared to higher-end brands.

5. McCormick Paints

Best For: Regional clients seeking eco-friendly, high-quality paint.
Price Range: $$

McCormick Paints is a standout option for those in the Mid-Atlantic region. This family-owned brand focuses on quality and sustainability, offering durable and vibrant lines like Generation LX. At Todd A. Hess Painting Co., we frequently use McCormick Paints for their balance of performance, eco-friendliness, and affordability.

Pros: Eco-friendly, exceptional quality, ideal for regional needs.
Cons: Limited availability outside the Mid-Atlantic.

Which Paint is Right for You?

Every project is unique, and the best paint choice depends on your needs. For long-lasting durability and high-traffic areas, Sherwin-Williams or Benjamin Moore may be the best fit. For budget-conscious options, Behr and Valspar deliver reliable results. If you’re in the Mid-Atlantic and value sustainability, McCormick Paints is an outstanding choice.

At Todd A. Hess Painting Co., we specialize in helping clients choose the right paint to match their vision. While we often recommend McCormick Paints for their quality and regional availability, we can work with any brand you prefer.

Contact us today to bring your vision to life with expert craftsmanship and high-quality paints tailored to your project’s unique needs!

Sign up for our Newsletter

We value privacy and will never share your information or email you without your permission.